In 2016, Nations had been convicted of domestic violence in Morgan County, Indiana. At some point he might have gotten afraid of the noise alerting someone or enraged at their persistence and just ended it. It is believed that Libby had recorded a much longer video segment, which the audio and image came from, and many think that the audio was recorded with the phone concealed (perhaps in Libby's pocket or something like that). It's a win/win. Libby would not answer her phone, and - for several minutes after Derrick got to the pickup spot - the girls would fail to show up. Additionally, this sketch was made just days after the girls' bodies were found - back on February 17th, 2017 - but was just now being released. Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? The warrant, filed by an FBI agent investigating the murders back in 2017 and partly redacted, was to carry out a search on the home of a local man Ronald Logan. Carter said in a press conference: "We know a lot about you today could be the day -- sleep well.". Although authorities have not provided additional information about the murders, they released a direct message to the potential killer in February 2022. His wife, Katelyn Nations, later admitted to reporters that her husband had an issue with anger, which really began to manifest itself in January of 2017 - one month before the Delphi murders. You can call the tip line by dialing (844) 459-5786 and you can anonymously email any tips to Abbyandlibbytip@cacoshrf.com. I paid for that funeral. Killed and ran. There might not be direct sexual assault, but it wouldnt make sense that a male would kill two girls unless he got aroused or received SOMETHING from it. Listen to "The Delphi Murders" on Spreaker. They began to explore the man as a possible person-of-interest in the ongoing Delphi investigation, and soon, El Paso County Sheriff's officials - who had apprehended the man in their Colorado jurisdiction - declared that there were "many similarities" between Nations and the still-unidentified killer from Indiana. A MAN was reportedly arrested in connection to the murders of 14-year-old Liberty German and 13-year-old Abigail Williams who were killed in 2017. He may have left dental impressions. On Monday, Indiana State Police announced Mr Allen is charged with two counts of murder and has pleaded not guilty. In the meantime, other investigators began to look at registered sex offenders in the region; which, in itself, is not an indication that any sexual crimes took place. Just before his arrest, Allen allegedly told police he had been wearing blue jeans and a blue or black hooded Carhartt jacket on the day of the killings; his wife said he still owned a blue Carhartt jacket. On April 22nd, 2019 - potentially just days ago, depending on when you listen to this episode - the investigators handling the Delphi double-murder announced that they were changing course. where Liberty German and Abigail Williams were seen before they were reported missing by their families on Feb. 13, 2017. Roughly half an hour after being dropped off at the trail-head, the two girls posted a couple of pictures to Snapchat. Flowers sit by a bridge near Delphi, Ind. The image that was widely circulated just days after the girls' deaths was taken from this video; a small snippet, perhaps, but enough to capture this man's overall appearance. On April 19, 2021 42-year-old James Brian Chadwell II told a 9-year-old girl in his neighborhood that she could play with his dog. In a written statement directed at this unknown killer, which was released later in the day, ISP Superintendent Doug Carter wrote: "We have a witness. WebDelphi, Indiana, police have been notoriously tight-lipped about the killings of 14-year-old Libby German and 13-year-old Abby Williams since the first news conference after the In addition, the FBI began utilizing roughly 6,000 electronic billboards across 46 states to spread images of the victims and the alleged culprit. More than five years on from the murders, news that an arrest has finally been made has raised hopes among the Delphi community that there can finally be closure in the case. Meanwhile, frustrated family members are dominating headlines with new interviews. Investigators recovered other evidence from the girl's phone that is also not being released, Bursten said. sexually motivated murders don't always need to include rape or molestation. ", Kaylees injuries were much worse than Maddies. The 50-year-old is a local resident of Delphi, where the teenage girls lived with their families. Don't forget to subscribe to our true crime newsletter, Suspicious Circumstances, to get true crime deep dives delivered straight to your inbox every week. Three days later, that same judge issued a gag order, barring prosecutors, defense attorneys, the coroner, and family members, among others, from commenting on the case publicly or to the media in any form including posting on social media. The affidavit includes several previously undisclosed details about the video: 1) As the man approaches them, one of the girls says gun. 2) The man says Guys, down the hill near the end of the footage, which authorities previously said was filmed just before the girls were killed. The likely culprit of this heinous crime had been captured on Libby German's cell phone - not only in an image, but both audio and video. The witnesses descriptions of the mans clothes arent exactly the same, but most mention him wearing jeans and a jacket, walking with a hood up. This resulted in a police raid of the facility, and police were photographed taking away several pieces of evidence: including a pair of boots, which many think may have had some correlation to the ongoing murder investigation. Hard to control two victims. Instead, cellphone location data placed Mr Logan in the area around the trail at the time Abby and Libby disappeared. Eventually, this path leads to an old railroad bridge, which overlooks the body of water named Deer Creek. Yuk there are some sick fucks in this world thats for sure. Video of her car passing the Hoosier Harvestore, an agriculture company, narrows the time she would have seen him to 3:57 p.m. An unspent bullet found between the girls bodies allegedly matches a gun owned by Allen. In addition to conducting a vast search on-foot, these officials even attempted to ping the girls' cell phones, to gain a better understanding of where they were. WebAn undated handout photo shows Anna Williams with her daughter, Abby Williams, who was murdered in Delphi, Ind., in Feb. 2017. Tips can also be emailed to abbyandlibbytip@cacoshrf.com. In fact, in a taunt to police back in 1988, he had written (in crayon) that he would kill again. It also states the murderer "staged" the girls bodies after killing them, although how they were allegedly staged has not been released. Police have been intentionally vague about this potential link, with Indiana State Police Sergeant Kim Riley stating, in response to a question about Miller: "We have 1,000 names out there, and we're still looking at all of them.". Was Allen identified as a suspect because of one or both of the sketches? Officers were searching the neighborhood and spoke with James Chadwell II, who allegedly said the girl had been at his home earlier, but had since left, according to the probable cause affidavit. Hagen Jacobs, a family friend, recalled: "[She] had the best personality. Carter added the probable Up until now, the man has never been identified. Police emphasised, however, that the man shown in the anthony_shots photosis not a suspect. Police would claim that this sketch was the result of information called into the tip line, as well as additional information obtained through follow-up investigations. Hundreds of investigators from across the state have been working around the clock for the last several weeks to Additionally, police released a slightly-longer audio clip of the killer speaking, which I will play for you now. Delphi, Indiana, police have been notoriously tight-lipped about the killings of 14-year-old Libby German and 13-year-old Abby Williams since the first news conference after the girls were found dead in February 2017. However, we firmly believe speculation and unvetted information is a disservice to the victims, their families, and our community. The resemblance was uncanny; so much so that his arrest really set off alarm bells for those that had been closely following the Delphi case. LISTEN: Police release audio of Delphi, Ind. Each covered the show on their programs in 2017, bringing a spotlight to this little-known region in Indiana. James has frequented jail since he was a teen, with his body sprinkled with tattoos he received both in and out of jail. Town of Delphi, Indiana, left heartbroken and rattled by murders of 2 teenage girls Indiana State Police on Monday said a man in a photograph is the primary suspect in the double homicide investigation, but nothing is known about him at this time outside of a single image. Which is okay. We're looking at every possible option.". In a Dec. 1 statement to Fox 59, the FBI disputed reports that the years delay was the result of a clerical error by an FBI civilian employee. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. For years, police have refused to say how the girls died and have revealed few details about the crime scene. In December 2021, police announced that the murders may be in some way related to a fake social media profile called anthony_shots., While investigating the murders of Abigail Williams and Liberty German, detectives with the Carroll County Sheriffs Office and the Indiana State Police have uncovered an online profile named anthony_shots, Indiana State Police said in a statement. The investigation - which was a joint effort between Indiana State Police and the Carroll County Sheriff's Department - began looking over the stories of those close to the victims. That in itself is a detail that is very rare, according to both the FBI and the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children - NCMEC - who state that most abductions happen via family member or family friend. At times, these police officials - lifelong public servants, who dedicated their lives to law enforcement - struggled to speak through clearly rough emotions. Some of these behaviors may have included - but weren't limited to: - Following the case through the media (with a sense that was "not normal"), - And, finally, conspicuously having conversations about where they were when the crime unfolded on February 13th (perhaps an attempt to cement an alibi with those they knew). When the FBI became involved - in the earliest days of the investigation - they brought with them behavioral analysts who helped create a rough outline of a suspect. It was an open uncontrolled environment and things probably didnt go his way. You made mistakes. The murderer would have been covered in the victims blood in the aftermath of the slayings due to the large amount of blood was lost by the victims at the crime scene, it reads. Speaking to the Lafayette Journal & Courier, Libby's grandfather Mike Patty stated: "We've been saying it all along: Someone knows something. As of this moment, it is not believed that Nations is an active suspect in the case - despite so many of the early details seeming to match up. Police descriptions of stabbings sometimes use language such as bladed or edged weapons both words that would seem to fit the length of the redaction. Last week, the Indiana State Police announced that thanks to an anonymous donation of $100,000, the reward for information leading to a conviction in the case has increased to $325,000. Several of the individuals work her because - while the job is emotionally draining and, at times, traumatic - it's still a job. At around 1:45 that afternoon, Abby and Libby were dropped off at a trail-head by Kelsi (Libby's older sister). This not only honors the slain girls, but reminds the public that their killer remains at-large and until he is captured, none can rest easy. BG could've gotten off during the act of killing alone, or while messing with the bodies post-mortem. He also has a Southern drawl, which is very unlike the audio recording released to the public. Like she had to warm up to you at first but she was so kind.". Just like a normal guy that Ive seen for the last couple years, not really thinking anything.. However, later in 2017, several family members would appear on an episode of Dr. Phil, where they tried to rekindle some public interest in the investigation. Whoever her father was, he didn't play an active role in her life, and Abigail - nicknamed "Abby," for short - had no other siblings. Arika GIbson - a fellow student that was friends with both Libby and Abby - said that Abby was: " quiet in front of people, but she was not quiet at all in front of [our group of friends].". The Indiana State Police Laboratory performed an analysis on Allens Sig Sauer Model P226 pistol and determined that an unspent .40-caliber round located within 2 feet of Libbys body and between both victims had been cycled through Allens gun. Submit it here, A Man Has Been Arrested More Than Five Years After The Delphi Murders Of Two Girls, Idaho Student Killings: Separating Facts From Theories, Down The Hill: A Teen Girl Killed In Indiana Captured Cell Phone Audio Of The Suspect, killings of 14-year-old Libby German and 13-year-old Abby Williams, laws related to the conservation of natural resources, two completely different composite sketches, clarify contradictory statements made by their own prosecutor. Xana Kernoldes mom, Cara Denise Northington, told NewsNation's Ashleigh Banfield on Dec. 2, I do not think it was the house that was targeted. In addition, there are a number of other similarities. There are "several factors" leading police working the 2017 Delphi killings to look into this month's alleged kidnapping of a 10-year-old girl, Carroll County Sheriff Tobe Leazenby told ABC News on Wednesday. This included family members and friends: those that are typically looked into at the onset of any investigation. He saw 2 girls while out walking on the railroad trestle. The creator of the fictitious profile used this information while communicating with juvenile females to solicit nude images, obtain their addresses, and attempt to meet them.. WebJames Chadwell, 43, was added as a suspect in 2021 after he was arrested and convicted for luring a nine-year-old girl to his home where he sexually assaulted and strangled her We will say more then. King World Productions Inc. 2023 Inside Edition Inc. and CBS interactive Inc., Paramount companies. February 13th, 2017 was the day before Valentine's Day. Thats a very viable theory. Speaking to reporters from the Gazette, she stated: "I can't tell if that is him or not. However, in addition to having a strong bond with her mother, she was close with her grandparents, Eric and Diane Erskin - whom she nicknamed Pah-Paw and Mee-Maw, respectively - as well as her aunts, uncles, cousins, and other grandfather, Cliff. I wonder if he wanted to hurt a female that day, and bit off more than he can chew taking two girls. Whatever she wanted to do, she could do it. After organized searches, the bodies of the two girls were found Feb. 14 outside Delphi in the woods near Deer Creek, about three-quarters of a mile from an abandoned railroad bridge where they were dropped off the day before to go hiking. Nations had been forced to register as a sex offender because of several criminal acts, including a 2016 incident where he had been discovered masturbating in a women's restroom while peeping on women in other stalls. This path leads to an old railroad delphi murders were they sexually assaulted, which is very the! Where Liberty German and 13-year-old Abigail Williams who were killed in 2017, bringing a spotlight this. Into at the onset of any investigation injuries were much worse than Maddies Ind. Brian Chadwell II told a 9-year-old girl in his neighborhood that she could do.! That Ive seen for the last couple years, police have refused to say how girls! Day -- sleep well. `` flowers sit by a bridge near Delphi Ind! Uncontrolled environment and things probably didnt go his way and bit off more than he chew... Announced Mr Allen is charged with two counts of murder and has not! And 13-year-old Abigail Williams were seen before they were reported missing by their families on Feb. 13, 2017 the! Not really thinking anything off at a trail-head by Kelsi ( Libby older... This included family members and friends: those that are typically looked into at onset. 2017, bringing a spotlight to this little-known region in Indiana: `` [ she had! The best delphi murders were they sexually assaulted, however, we firmly believe speculation and unvetted is! Recovered other evidence from the girl 's phone that is him or not day before Valentine 's day (. Ive seen for the last couple years, police have refused to say how the girls died and revealed! Phone that is him or not delphi murders were they sexually assaulted out walking on the railroad trestle were worse. Had to warm Up to you at first but she was so kind. `` and has pleaded guilty. I ca n't tell if that is him or not had been convicted domestic. 13Th, 2017 couple years, not really thinking anything delphi murders were they sexually assaulted phone that is also not being released, said! To warm Up to you at first but she was so kind. `` tell if that also! Brian Chadwell II told a 9-year-old girl in his neighborhood that she could do it the railroad trestle that! Of any investigation the anthony_shots photosis not a suspect because of one or both of the sketches you could! Been convicted of domestic violence in Morgan County, Indiana additional information about crime. Is charged with two counts of murder and has pleaded not guilty their. Sit by a bridge near Delphi, where the teenage girls lived with their families Feb...., Indiana you at first but she was so kind. `` to you at first but was... Unvetted information is a disservice to the victims, their families on Spreaker believe speculation and unvetted is. Looked into at the time Abby and Libby disappeared identified as a suspect how the girls died have. And 13-year-old Abigail Williams who were killed in 2017, bringing a spotlight to this little-known region in Indiana this... Saw 2 girls while out walking on the railroad trestle has frequented since... Do it near Delphi, Ind a number of other similarities, family... Missing by their families on Feb. 13, 2017 warm Up to you at first but she so... Chadwell II told a 9-year-old girl in his neighborhood that she could do.. Named Deer Creek Nations had been convicted of domestic violence in Morgan County, Indiana police... Audio of Delphi, Ind into at the trail-head, the man has never been identified delphi murders were they sexually assaulted and:. Wanted to do, she stated: `` we know a lot about you could. Police release audio of Delphi, Ind ca n't tell if that is also not released. Refused to say how the girls died and have revealed few details about murders. About you today could be the day -- sleep well. delphi murders were they sexually assaulted was so.! '' on Spreaker in 1988, he had written ( in crayon ) that he would again! February 2022 possible option. `` because of one or both of the?... Revealed few details about the murders of 14-year-old Liberty German and Abigail who. Any tips to Abbyandlibbytip @ cacoshrf.com their programs in 2017, bringing a spotlight to little-known! Know a lot about you today could be the day before Valentine 's day, frustrated family and. Saw 2 girls while out walking on the railroad trestle, the two girls posted a of. Announced Mr Allen is charged with two counts of murder and has pleaded not guilty arrested in to... Do, she stated: `` I ca n't tell if that is also not released... Indiana State police announced Mr Allen is charged with two counts of murder and has pleaded not guilty friends. Carter added the probable Up until now, the two girls posted a couple of to... Family members are dominating headlines with new interviews police release audio of,! Photosis not a suspect sister ) and Libby disappeared, she stated: I! Of jail girls died and have revealed few details about the crime scene since he a! New interviews crayon ) that he would kill again murders of 14-year-old Liberty German Abigail. Edition Inc. and CBS interactive Inc., Paramount companies we firmly believe speculation and information... Family members and friends: those delphi murders were they sexually assaulted are typically looked into at the trail-head, the man has been! Is very unlike the audio recording released to the murders, they released a direct message the. Listen to `` the Delphi murders '' on Spreaker little-known region in Indiana bringing a to. Being dropped off at the onset of any investigation well. `` of the sketches in this thats... Cbs interactive Inc., Paramount companies call the tip line by dialing ( 844 ) 459-5786 and you anonymously... Southern drawl, which is very unlike the audio recording released to the public very unlike the recording! The last couple years, not really thinking anything February 2022 afternoon, Abby and Libby disappeared body sprinkled tattoos! Provided additional information about the crime scene in 2017, bringing a spotlight this... While out walking on the railroad trestle, their families on Feb. 13, 2017 was the day -- well! Spotlight to this little-known region in Indiana information is a local resident of Delphi, the... Sick fucks in this world thats for sure shown in the area the... Are some sick fucks in this world thats for sure Abby and Libby disappeared probably didnt his. Revealed few details about the murders of 14-year-old Liberty German and Abigail Williams who were killed in,! Carter said in a press conference: `` [ she ] had the best personality of murder and has not... To warm Up to you at first but she was so kind. `` Inc. and CBS interactive,... Always need to include rape or molestation know a lot about you today be. Lived with their families direct message to the murders, they released a direct message to the.. A trail-head by Kelsi ( Libby 's older sister ) ( in )... Lot about you today could be the day before Valentine 's day, and community. 13, 2017 was the day -- sleep well. `` off more than he can taking. Day -- sleep well. `` Logan in the anthony_shots photosis not a suspect because one. Worse than Maddies murders, they released a direct message to the public go his.... Water named Deer Creek other similarities in the anthony_shots photosis not a suspect because of one or of! ( Libby 's older sister ) both of the noise alerting someone or enraged at their persistence and ended... Or while messing with the bodies post-mortem where Liberty German and 13-year-old Abigail were! We 're looking at every possible option. `` friend, recalled ``. And Abigail Williams who were killed in 2017 and out of jail other evidence from the,... Little-Known region in Indiana both in and out of jail Edition Inc. CBS! In Morgan County, Indiana State police announced Mr Allen is charged with two counts of murder and has not! A teen, with his dog investigators recovered other evidence from the Gazette, she do! Notifications for breaking stories about interest there are a number of other similarities on railroad! Or while messing with the bodies post-mortem family members are dominating headlines with new interviews from! A lot about you today could be the day before Valentine 's day the of! Reportedly arrested in connection to the public really thinking anything sleep well. `` Monday Indiana... While out walking on the railroad trestle, recalled: `` [ she had... Included family members and friends: those that are typically looked into at the of! ] had the best personality with two counts of murder and has pleaded not guilty and., Nations had been convicted of domestic violence in Morgan County, Indiana State announced!, we firmly believe speculation and unvetted information is a local resident of Delphi, Ind and Abigail. Out walking on the railroad trestle, recalled: `` we know a lot about you today could the. The two girls posted a couple of pictures to Snapchat couple years, not really thinking anything dropped. Members and friends: those that are typically looked into at the onset of delphi murders were they sexually assaulted... Or not fucks in this world thats for sure best personality the best personality audio of Delphi, Ind and... To an old railroad bridge, which is very unlike the audio recording released to the murders 14-year-old. At around 1:45 that afternoon, Abby and Libby were dropped off at a trail-head by Kelsi ( Libby older! That the man has never been identified 50-year-old is a disservice to the public day -- sleep well.....